Carley vs Caitlyn
Caitlyn leads today (#2,485 vs #2,719), though both are past their peak.
145 years, head to head
Babies named Carley and Caitlyn per year in U.S. Social Security records, 1880–2025.
Head to head
2025 rank
#2,719
#2,485
Babies named in 2025
63
71
Peak year
1998
1998
Trend
Declining since 1997
Declining since 1999
Usually for
Girls
Girls
Lifetime births
16,918
52,603
Try another matchup
Carley against names whose popularity has moved like its own.